I take your point CKLD, particularly as I'm in exactly that position myself, but not everyone gets on with ADs - for some they cause horrendous side-effects and for others they simply don't work. I think the whole thing is way more complicated than there being one appropriate mode of treatment, and I have to say I've changed my opinion a bit in the months I've been suffering from hormone-related depression and anxiety. I do think hormones are at the root and I do think I'll eventually find a hormonal solution, but in the meantime I've had to accept that ADs may give me temporary respite from these horrible symptoms. However, I've had a lot of trouble with ADs in the past, SSRIs most definitely don't agree with me. I'm now reluctantly trying a low dose of amitryptiline, which so far is making me more depressed than I was before and not doing a huge amount for the anxiety. Hanging on in there as I know it can take a while (been nearly 2 weeks now). Really I just wanted to make the point that ADs may've worked well for you, but that isn't always the case, sometimes thay create more problems than they solve, and also many GPs use them as the end solution rather than investigating the causes further.