Hi northseacrashes
Good job you have done your research! yes your doctor is quite wrong. You have reached menopause if you have gone 12 months without a bleed and that's that. This is not to say that you will never have another bleed - but it is the point beyond which any further bleeding is referred for investigation to rule out endometrial cancer. You can only date menopause in retrospect and in many cases ( like me) if you start HRT before getting there - you never know exactly when it would have happened.
Yes the average age of menopause is around 51/52 and your doc should be aware both of this website and the NICE Guidelines, which state respectively that up to to the age of 60 if you are experiencing menopausal symptoms then the benefits of HRT exceed the risks, and secondly that there is no age limit for taking HRT provided that the risks ( as are known) are explained and that you accept them - and are not contra-indicated medically.
She should also know that some women continue to experience menopausal symptoms for years and there is n knowing whether you will be one of them - so why stop after two years just to see?
I hope the Elleste works for you and you feel better soon. Do expect your body to go through a period of adjustment and you will have a withdrawal bleed every month - but if these are not ideal - there are plenty more to choose from.
Good luck and let us know how you get on
Hurdity x
Edit - I see while I was writing you;ve had other replies - good job we all agree!