PompeyLou, this gets more frightening by the day, this bloke sounds incompetent and I think you should report him. What the hell is he talking about, it clearly states and I quote "A SEPARATE PROGESTERONE SHOULD NOT BE ADDED TO LIVIAL".
If he is going to make your life a misery by taking you off Livial then he must explain in precise detail why he thinks you are particularly at risk from this product when millions of other women are not. He knows your history and he knows what coming off Livial has done to you yet he just sits on his backside and tells you to suck it up.
I think he is dangerous and putting women at risk and yet again it's the proverbial doctor (gynaecologist this time which is even worse) not understanding HRT being the same as a referee who doesn't understand the offside rule.